Here’s a detailed and expanded rewrite of the article about José Iglesias’ impact in 2024 and why the Mets should bring him back

Ankit Puri12 hours ago

A Surprising Star Emerges in Queens

The 2024 MLB season saw several standout performances from the New York Mets, but few were as surprising as José Iglesias’ incredible impact on both offense and defense. Originally signed as a depth piece, Iglesias quickly became one of the Mets’ most reliable players, providing consistent hitting, elite defense, and leadership.

Meanwhile, Pete Alonso, one of the Mets’ biggest stars and home run leaders, had a solid but inconsistent season. While Alonso continued to showcase his power at the plate, his struggles with batting average, on-base percentage, and strikeouts raised concerns about his overall value compared to a well-rounded player like Iglesias.

Now, with Iglesias entering free agency, the Mets must make a crucial decision: Should they bring him back for 2025? Given his all-around contributions, the answer should be a resounding yes.

José Iglesias vs. Pete Alonso: A Tale of Two Seasons

At first glance, it might seem unfair to compare Iglesias, a contact-hitting utility infielder, to Alonso, a slugging first baseman. However, when analyzing their overall value to the Mets in 2024, Iglesias’ impact in both offense and defense cannot be ignored.

1. Offensive Contributions: Iglesias’ Consistency vs. Alonso’s Power-Dependent Play

José Iglesias (2024 Season Stats):

Batting Average: .337
On-Base Percentage (OBP): .381
Slugging Percentage (SLG): .448
Home Runs: 4
RBIs: 26
Strikeouts: Low
WAR (Wins Above Replacement): 5.2

Pete Alonso (2024 Season Stats):

Batting Average: .238
On-Base Percentage (OBP): .319
Slugging Percentage (SLG): .486
Home Runs: 43
RBIs: 103
Strikeouts: High
WAR (Wins Above Replacement): 3.9

While Alonso’s power numbers remain elite, his high strikeout rate and inconsistent batting average made him a boom-or-bust hitter. On the other hand, Iglesias’ ability to make contact, get on base, and provide clutch hits gave the Mets a more balanced offensive approach.

2. Defensive Prowess: Iglesias’ Versatility vs. Alonso’s Limited Role

Defensively, Iglesias was one of the most valuable players on the Mets’ roster. His ability to play multiple infield positions (shortstop, second base, and third base) gave the Mets crucial flexibility, especially when injuries struck.

Iglesias’ 2024 Defensive Stats:

Fielding Percentage: .990
Errors: 3
Defensive Runs Saved (DRS): +12

Alonso’s 2024 Defensive Stats (1B Only):

Fielding Percentage: .987
Errors: 7
Defensive Runs Saved (DRS): -4

While Alonso held his own at first base, Iglesias’ range, quick reflexes, and highlight-reel plays made him a true defensive asset. In fact, Iglesias’ diving stop on August 26, 2024, was named MLB’s “Play of the Week.” (MLB.com)

With the Mets struggling defensively throughout the season, Iglesias’ elite glove and versatility were invaluable.

3. Clubhouse Leadership & Fan Favorite Status

Beyond stats, Iglesias became a leader in the Mets’ clubhouse. His work ethic, positive attitude, and veteran presence made him a role model for younger players. Teammates praised his professionalism, and fans embraced him as an underdog success story.

By contrast, Alonso faced increased scrutiny regarding his future with the team. With contract negotiations looming and questions about whether the Mets will extend him or explore a trade, his long-term status in Queens remains uncertain.

Why the Mets Must Re-Sign Iglesias for 2025 and Beyond

Given everything Iglesias provided in 2024, it’s clear that the Mets should not let him walk in free agency. Here’s why:

1. The Mets Need Contact Hitters

The Mets struggled with strikeouts and runners in scoring position last year. Iglesias’ .337 average and high contact rate are exactly what the team needs to balance a power-heavy lineup.

2. Defensive Stability & Versatility

The Mets’ defense ranked among the worst in MLB in several key categories. Bringing back Iglesias ensures elite infield defense at multiple positions.

3. Cost-Effective Option

Unlike Alonso, who could command a massive long-term contract, Iglesias won’t break the bank. A two-year, $12-15 million deal would be a low-risk, high-reward move.

4. Insurance for Future Roster Moves

With uncertainty surrounding Alonso’s future, retaining Iglesias gives the Mets flexibility. If they trade Alonso, Iglesias could help solidify the infield while younger prospects develop.

Final Verdict: José Iglesias Deserves to Return

While Pete Alonso remains a home run powerhouse, José Iglesias outperformed expectations in 2024 and proved to be one of the Mets’ most valuable all-around players. His elite defense, consistent hitting, and leadership make him a must-have piece for the team’s 2025 playoff push.

If the Mets are serious about building a balanced, championship-caliber team, they must re-sign Iglesias before another team snatches him up.

Mets fans, what do you think? Should the team prioritize bringing back Iglesias for 2025? Drop your thoughts below! ⚾🔵🟠

Would you like any further refinements or additional details?